do you prefer to start with the melody or the words?

In the realm of songwriting, there exists a longstanding debate regarding whether to initiate the process by crafting the lyrics or composing the melody. This discussion is not merely academic; it deeply impacts the creative journey and the final product. To delve into this intriguing subject, we must explore the perspectives of those who prioritize one aspect over the other, and how these preferences shape their approach to songwriting.

The Melody First Approach

For many musicians, starting with the melody is akin to capturing the heartbeat of the song. Proponents of this method argue that melodies have a way of evoking emotions and setting the tone for the lyrics. The melodic line can act as a foundation upon which the words are built, allowing the composer to build around an already established framework. This perspective suggests that once the melody is in place, the lyrical content can be tailored to complement and enhance the musical piece.

One such artist who embodies this approach is Ed Sheeran. His songs often begin with a catchy tune that then becomes the anchor for his poetic and heartfelt lyrics. The melody serves as a vehicle through which he expresses his emotions, making his work deeply relatable and emotionally resonant. By focusing on the melody first, Ed Sheeran ensures that every note has a purpose and contributes to the overall narrative of his song.

The Lyrics First Approach

On the other hand, some songwriters find that writing the lyrics first allows them to establish the story or message they wish to convey. This method encourages creativity and spontaneity, as the words come first, and the melody emerges organically. Those who favor this approach believe that lyrics provide the structure and meaning that the melody needs to breathe life into. In this way, the lyrics serve as the blueprint for the song, guiding the musician in creating a harmonious whole.

A prime example of a lyric-first approach is Taylor Swift. Her songs frequently start with a vivid narrative or poignant reflection, and the melody follows suit, enhancing the emotional depth of her lyrics. By crafting the words first, Taylor Swift ensures that each note she adds aligns perfectly with the intended message, resulting in a cohesive and powerful musical experience.

Balancing Both Approaches

While both methods have their merits, many successful songwriters employ a blend of both strategies. They might begin with a melodic idea, then flesh out the lyrics to make the melody more meaningful. Alternatively, they may start with the lyrics, allowing the melody to emerge naturally as they refine the musical arrangement. This balanced approach acknowledges the interdependence between lyrics and melody, ensuring that each element supports and enriches the other.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the choice of starting with lyrics or melody depends on individual artistic preferences and the specific needs of the song. Each method offers unique advantages and can lead to a rich and fulfilling creative process. Whether a songwriter begins with the melody or the lyrics, the goal remains the same: to create music that resonates with listeners and touches their hearts.